Intersectional Identities of Queer Asian American Women

by Adain L.

[1]

Introduction

~

Introduction ~

Intersectionality, despite its drastic rise in visibility, is not a new concept. However, one might be led to believe so when looking at previous battles such as the fight for women’s suffrage and equal rights and the fight for queer liberation. Both have been overpowered by whiteness, with the fight for queer liberation being especially marred by the perception that queerness and whiteness are one in the same, as well as queerness most commonly being associated with men, creating a sense that the default queer person is a gay white man.[1] This leaves women of color invisible in queer representation, which is especially dangerous because of the unique problems that they face. Queer Asian American women face significant issues regarding their identity because of American society’s preconceived notions of Asian women coupled with the fear of being in unaccepting, traditional families and social groups. This exhibit will discuss the problems that plague queer Asian American women, and how they must be selective in their socialization to avoid negative mental health outcomes.

This exhibit, while not solely about it, is centered on the 2020 debut album SAWAYAMA by Rina Sawayama. Rina Sawayama is a queer British Asian woman, and the SAWAYAMA album touches on themes relating to identity, including careful socialization and fetishization. She also discusses alienation and the feeling of being a perpetual foreigner in the lead up to the 2020 award season. It is important to note that Rina is a British Asian immigrant from Japan. While there are differences in the experience of Asians in the United Kingdom versus the United States, the relative cultural similarity and universal nature of Rina’s work allows her themes to apply to Asian Americans.

Key Concepts

~

Theoretical Framework

~

Key Concepts ~ Theoretical Framework ~

  • Exclusive sexual attraction towards a different, minoritized racial group.

  • The theory of minority health outcomes being worse than non-minorities because of a disproportionate exposure to stress as a result of their marginalized identity.

  • The “process through which children learn about the social expectations, attitudes and behaviors typically associated with boys and girls.”

  • The stereotype that ethnic minorities will always been seen as the out-group in classical White Anglo-Saxon American culture.

Minority Stress Theory is an especially pertinent theory regarding queer people of color, as they are likely to be subjected to higher amounts of stress as a result of more exposure to discrimination due to their minoritized race and sexuality. Stressors regarding their race can, and often times does, compound stressors related to their sexuality. It is also possible for their race and sexuality to affect each other to cause stress. Because of the overwhelming whiteness of much of the queer community, many queer people of color find themselves struggling to find accepting queer groups that are able to understand the struggles of being a racial minority in addition to being queer. This has been seen in queer advocacy groups, where white voices and issues are centered, and Black and Brown voices are spoken over.[1] It is also hard for some queer people of color to seek racial community groups, as not every group will be welcoming to queer people, as evidenced by the rejection of lesbianism as a western “foreign import” among West African football coaches for the Women’s World Cup.[6] As such, it is important for queer people of color to find community with other queer people of color, as the level of understanding between them is higher. This is seen amongst the queer population of L.A., especially in the ‘90s, through Brown and Gay in LA by Anthony Ocampo.[7]

In addition to finding accepting groups, queer people may also find queer communities that align with their race to avoid racial fetishization. Despite some that might argue that racial fetishization is complimentary, it is still psychologically damaging for racial minorities. Racial fetishization is predicated on the sexualization of a culture and the dehumanization of the person by placing them into preconceived sexual roles based off of racial and cultural stereotypes.² This is especially true for Asian women, who have historically been casted as sexually devious, docile, and submissive.[8] This is something that is taught to young Asian girls through gender and racial socialization as well, where they learn the behaviors and attitudes that they are expected to perform as Asian girls.[9] It is extremely important to note the use of fetishization, especially of Asian women, as a tool of white supremacy. Using racial fetishization, White Christians have tried to subjugate Asian Americans and force them into a perpetual state of being foreign by blaming Asian women for their sexual deviance corrupting White men.[10]

SAWAYAMA Overview

~

SAWAYAMA Overview ~

[2]

Cover art for SAWAYAMA

SAWAYAMA is the debut album of British-Japanese artist Rina Sawayama and was released in March of 2020. The album’s themes are centered around family and identity, ranging from talking about fetishization to feeling isolated from her home country of Japan.[11] Despite being British, these themes can be easily applicable to the Asian American community because of their universality. The album achieved critical acclaim, appearing on multiple year-end Best Album lists.

SAWAYAMA Themes

~

SAWAYAMA Themes ~

Asian Fetishization

~

Gender Socialization

~

Asian Fetishization ~ Gender Socialization ~

In Rina’s third and fourth tracks, “STFU!” and “Comme Des Garçons (Like The Boys)”, she tackles the issues of fetishization and the double standards regarding confident women. Asian women frequently have to deal with people with “yellow fever”, a slang term for an Asian fetish. There is a strong historical context for Asian fetishes, especially among White men, where Asian women are portrayed and thus monolithically thought of as sexual deviants, conservative, docile, and submissive, and were as such the ideal sexual partner. This would then often shift the blame for the White man’s hypersexuality onto the Asian women he pursued, saying that they were a corrupting force.[10] This reasoning would be used to excuse anti-Asian laws and to rationalize violence against Asian Americans. In March 2021, Robert Long shot and killed 8 and injured 1 at 3 Asian spas in the Atlanta area. He called the spas “a temptation for him that he wanted to eliminate”, showing that, despite the locations just being spas and massage parlors, the fact that they were Asian made them inherently sexual in his view.[12]

Rachelle Ann Gao as Gigi in Miss Saigon

[3]

Minority Stress Theory is an extremely important theory in regards to the mental health outcomes for minority groups. It becomes especially salient when talking about minoritized racial groups that are also sexual minorities. This is because of something called the buffer hypothesis. The buffer hypothesis posits that strong social support can “buffer” the pathogenic effects of stress.[14] Social support thus becomes exponentially more important for queer people of color.

Drawing for The Confusing Intersectionality of the Queer Asian Identity

A Good Morning America video about an online community of queer Asian women and nonbinaries (above) and a collage for For Queer Asians, Community Means Family (below)

[5]

SAWAYAMA Track No. 3, “STFU!” and Track No. 4, “Comme Des Garçons (Like The Boys)”

Asian women have been portrayed as sexually deviant in media for over a century, which helps perpetuate the stereotype. Rachel Ramirez’s Vox article explains the history of the sexualization of Asian women, showing how Asian women were banned from being imported for fears that they were engaging in prostitution, despite the lack of base.[8] The stereotype of Asian women also being quiet and docile play into how young Asian girls are socialized. Through gender and racial socialization, Asian girls are taught, sometimes by their own parents, that in order to perform their Asianness and their womanhood, they should be quiet and repress their own sexuality.[9] Confidence is often seen as abrasive, even though confidence is one of the main tenets of how boys are socialized. Rina addresses this in “Comme Des Garçons (Like The Boys)”, where she subverts expected gender roles by exclaiming things like “I’m so confident” and “Excuse my ego”, while telling girls “…it’s okay, you should never be ashamed to have it all”.[13]

Minority Stress

~

Selective Socialization

~

Minority Stress ~ Selective Socialization ~

[4]

However, if it is their intersecting identities that makes social support more important, it is also their intersecting identities that makes finding social support more difficult. If a queer Asian were to look for a queer community for support, they can be faced with overwhelming Whiteness and experience race-based discrimination.[15] If they were to go to their Asian community for support, they might find that there is little to no queer representation in their circle. As a result, in order to not be forced to sacrifice one identity for the other, an affinity group that is catered to their intersecting identities is crucial. Otherwise, it can be hard for queer Asians, especially in their youth, to find comfort in their intertwined identities, which Kay Patel talks about in her op-ed The Confusing Intersectionality of the Queer Asian Identity.[16] It is especially hard to embrace your entire identity when you belong to a racial group that oftentimes sees part of you as a disturbance or burden to the norm.

SAWAYAMA Track No. 11, “Chosen Family”

When a queer Asian is finally able to find a support system, the mental health outcomes are great. Because they are in a group that understands their struggles, they are set up for the buffer hypothesis to be more successful. When a member of the group goes through a stressful event related to their identity, they will have a group of people that share that identity to support them through the stressful event. This is what the Good Morning America video about Subtle Asian Sapphic Squad (SASS), Xtra article For Queer Asians, Community Means Family, and the 11th track of SAWAYAMA, “Chosen Family”, are about. SASS is an online community of over 7,000 members at the time of Good Morning America’s coverage, and the event coordinator, Chieko, described the group as “…your closest group of friends”. Chieko also said that she feels like she can relax more in SASS than she can in a White space. Other members expressed how good SASS has been for their mental health, especially since they felt like they had to hide their identity originally because of cultural norms.[17] The Xtra article highlights queer Asian communities in Canada and how liberating it is for some people to be able to blend their sexuality or gender expression with their culture. The group is especially important because it also gives queer Asian youth a space to find community and to see adults like them living their lives, something Kay Patel expressed she felt lost about, as she hadn’t seen queer Asian adults in her life that could show her healthy relationships with their identities.[16][18] Rina expresses the same sentiment about finding community in “Chosen Family”, the 11th track of SAWAYAMA. “Chosen Family” is explicitly about using communities to help each other get over stressors and pain that they’ve suffered through, using the term chosen family, which has been used extensively within the queer community. Rina describes the buffer hypothesis in her verses, singing “Give me a pen and I’ll rewrite the pain”.[19]

Perpetual Foreigner

~

Perpetual Foreigner ~

[6]

Rina Sawayama for Rolling Stones UK following the release of her second album, Hold the Girl

The stereotype of the perpetual foreigner isn’t confined to the United States. The United Kingdom, which is even more White than the U.S., also has the stereotype that ethnic minorities will always be the other group. Americanness or Britishness is seen as synonymous with Whiteness, which is evident when thinking about how Asian American and British Asian are “hyphenated” nationalities, but White Brits and Americans are almost always just called British or American. Rina Sawayama expressed in 2020 a feeling of being “forever foreign” after she was not considered for the BRIT Awards or the Mercury Prize because of her citizenship.[20] This is because, prior to the controversy surrounding Rina’s snub, you had to be a citizen to be considered. However, Rina was not a citizen, but a permanent resident, as citizenship would force her to renounce her Japanese citizenship (since Japan doesn’t permit dual citizenship). This was upsetting for Rina, who considers herself a British woman and had been living in the country for 25 years. Unlike with the intersection of queerness and Asianness, the intersection of being a minoritized race and your nationality can’t be so easily buffered with social support, especially since race is immediately detectable, unlike queerness. This leads to the age old question of “where are you really from?”, which carries the connotation that Asian Americans aren’t really American and British Asians aren’t really British.[21]

Conclusion

~

Conclusion ~

Rina discusses so many facets of being queer, Asian, and a woman in SAWAYAMA and her sophomore album, Hold the Girl. While it would be impossible to showcase everything said in these albums, it goes to show that, while carrying a large scope of womanhood, Asianness, queerness, and nationality, this essay cannot possibly touch on every poignant topic in regards to the Asian American community. And though Rina isn’t American and as such possesses a great deal of different experience than many in the Asian American community, the experiences in SAWAYAMA are universal enough to be able to find applicability in Asian American studies.

Return to Asian American Sound Home

References

~

References ~

  1. Nicholas F. Havey, “"I Can’t Be Racist, I’m Gay”: Exploring Queer White Men’s Views on Race and Racism,” JCSCORE 7, no. 2 (November 22, 2021): 136–72, https://doi.org/10.15763/issn.2642-2387.2021.7.2.136-172.

  2. Hannah Kim-Cragg, “Day 13: Unmasking Racial Fetishization,” 40 Days of Engagement on Anti-Racism, October 2021, https://united-church.ca/sites/default/files/2021-10/antiracism-40_day13.pdf.

  3. David M. Frost and Ilan H. Meyer, “Minority Stress Theory: Application, Critique, and Continued Relevance,” Current Opinion in Psychology 51 (April 2023): 101579, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2023.101579.

  4. “Gender: Early Socialization,” Encyclopedia on Early Childhood Development, accessed December 10, 2023, https://www.child-encyclopedia.com/gender-early-socialization#:~:text=Gender%20socialization%20is%20the%20process,influence%20gender%20development%20in%20children

  5. Que-Lam Huynh, Thierry Devos, and Laura Smalarz, “Perpetual Foreigner in One’s Own Land: Potential Implications for Identity and Psychological Adjustment,” Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 30, no. 2 (February 2011): 133–62, https://doi.org/10.1521/jscp.2011.30.2.133.

  6. Anima Adjepong, “With All Eyes on the Women’s World Cup, It’s Time to Stop Focusing on Players’ Sexuality,” The Guardian, August 4, 2023, https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/aug/04/with-all-eyes-on-the-womens-world-cup-its-time-to-stop-focusing-on-players-sexuality.

  7. Anthony Christian Ocampo, Brown and Gay in LA: The Lives of Immigrant Sons (New York, NY: New York University Press, 2023).

  8. Rachel Ramirez, “The History of Fetishizing Asian Women,” Vox, March 19, 2021, https://www.vox.com/22338807/asian-fetish-racism-atlanta-shooting.

  9. Lydia HaRim Ahn et al., “Second-Generation Asian American Women’s Gendered Racial Socialization.,” Journal of Counseling Psychology 69, no. 2 (March 2022): 129–45, https://doi.org/10.1037/cou0000575.

  10. Aki Uchida, “The Orientalization of Asian Women in America,” Women’s Studies International Forum 21, no. 2 (March 1998): 161–74, https://doi.org/10.1016/s0277-5395(98)00004-1.

  11. Matthew Strauss, “Rina Sawayama Announces Tour and Debut Album, Shares New Song: Listen,” Pitchfork, January 17, 2020, https://pitchfork.com/news/rina-sawayama-announces-tour-and-debut-album-shares-new-song-listen/.

  12. Jenna Hillhouse, “Atlanta Spa Shootings,” Homeland Security Digital Library, August 25, 2022, https://www.hsdl.org/c/tl/atlanta-spa-shootings/.

  13. Rina Sawayama, “Comme Des Garçons (Like The Boys)” by Rina Sawayama, Nicole Morier, and Bram Inscore, track 4 on SAWAYAMA, Dirty Hit, streaming.

  14. Sheldon Cohen and Garth McKay, “Social Support, Stress and The Buffering Hypothesis: A Theoretical Analysis,” Handbook of Psychology and Health (Volume IV), August 31, 2020, 253–67, https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003044307-10.

  15. Terence H. Ching et al., “A Model of Intersectional Stress and Trauma in Asian American Sexual and Gender Minorities.,” Psychology of Violence 8, no. 6 (November 2018): 657–68, https://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000204.

  16. Kay Patel, “The Confusing Intersectionality of the Queer Asian Identity,” The Talon, August 2020, https://lahstalon.org/intersectionality-of-asian-queer-identities/.

  17. Good Morning America, How LGBTQ Asian women are finding and creating community online l GMA. YouTube, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtaGfXoTIko.

  18. Diamond Yao, “For Queer Asians, Community Means Family,” Xtra Magazine, October 13, 2022, https://xtramagazine.com/power/identity/queer-asian-community-237059.

  19. Rina Sawayama, “Chosen Family” by Rina Sawayama, track 11 on SAWAYAMA, Dirty Hit, streaming.

  20. Justin Curto, “Rina Sawayama Says Citizenship Clause Keeps Her out of Brits, Mercury Prize,” Vulture, July 29, 2020, https://www.vulture.com/2020/07/rina-sawayama-ineligible-british-awards.html.

  21. Sapna Cheryan and Benoit Monin, “‘Where Are You Really from?’: Asian Americans and Identity Denial,” PsycEXTRA Dataset, November 2005, https://doi.org/10.1037/e633942013-184.

Photo References

~

Photo References ~